Notes and bibliography, which works with footnotes or endnotes, often accompanied by a bibliography. Other style guides may have different rules and guidelines. The following chart shows some of the major differences in punctuation style between the associated press stylebook 2018 edition and the chicago manual of style 17th edition. Whenever there is a list, they say, the oxford comma should be included. Chicago, being twice as long as ap, has twice as much to say on this subject and offers several more variations of proper serial comma usage on which the ap is mum 6. This comma precedes the final item in a list or series, before the word and or or. A majority of american style guides mandate use of the serial comma, including apa style, the chicago manual of style, garners modern american usage, the mla style manual, strunk and whites elements of style and the u. The best name would be terminal serial comma, since all the ones preceding it are also serial commas in the sense of commas in a series. Buying the chicago manual of style is a nobrainer for writers. The 15th edition of the chicago manual of style has been superseded by the 17th edition. There are several uses of the comma that can best be described as conventional or mechanical. This style guide is mainly used in most longform publishing. In answer to a readers query, the chicago manual of style online notes that their style guide has been recommending use of the serial comma ever since the first edition in 1906, but also qualifies this, saying the serial comma is optional.
In one corner, we have the chicago manual of style cms, currently in its sixteenth edition and beloved most in the arena of book publishing. The guidelines for chicago style writing are laid out in the chicago manual of style most recently in its 16th edition. Also called the oxford comma, this term refers to a comma that separates the penultimate item in a list from the final item introduced by a conjunction and or or. Turabians manual for writers of research papers, theses, and dissertations 8th ed. In the united states, the leading style guides are the chicago manual of style and the associated press.
For example, in the sentence were going to the store to get an apple. When listing words or phrases, if you have three or more in the list, then you need to place a comma before the coordinating conjunction and, or that precedes the final element in the list. In published books, at least in englishback then as nowthe serial comma was common. Time according to chicago manual of style blue dragon. Jan 08, 20 the onion posted a funny well, funny to me article yesterday about copy editing. The oxford comma also called the serial comma is one of the most divisive linguistic devices in the english language. Cmos generally prescribes the oxford comma, stating. This article is about serialcomma rule red, white, and blue enjoy your reading. However, the ap style rule is that you do not include that final comma unless. When a conjunction joins the last two elements in a series, a comma known as the serial or series comma or the oxford comma should appear before the conjunction.
So those are the major chicago manual of style updates, although im sure there will be many more small changes to discover once. In the other corner, we have the associated press stylebook ap, the most widely. Shorter adverbial phrases are less likely to merit a comma than longer ones. Subscribers to the chicago manual of style online may click through to the linked sections of the manual. Since breaking news of the 17th edition, out in september, the university of chicago press has revealed some major revisions to the chicago manual of style. The chicago manual of style supports the serial comma, and so do the elements of style by strunk and white, fowlers modern english usage and other traditionoriented guides.
Those in the publishing industry will need this edition, both for whats new. You say in reply to an inquiry about the use of serial commas that you wonder where the notion got started that there shouldnt be any comma before the conjunction joining a string of words or phrases to the very last one in the series. If a potential employer decided to test you on that claim, would. Following are some of the most common style situations that come up and how to handle them, taking specific cr conventions. I wonder if you really meant the oxford comma the comma before the last item. Commas, semicolons, and colons the chicago school of. The chicago manual of style by university of chicago press. The use or omission of the comma is well established, and writers need only to apply the rules. The mla style manual aff links, which is the primary style resource in academics, also supports use of the serial comma. Chicago strongly recommends this widely practiced usage. Its generic name is the serial or series comma, but a lot of people refer to it by a fancier name. Sabr style guide society for american baseball research. If youre in a discipline that uses one of these manuals, then, when in doubt, put the comma in. In short, aps stance is to omit the serial comma except when it prevents misreading, and chicago s stance is to always include itfor the same reason.
Cmos generally prescribes the oxford comma, stating that it prevents confusion such as that shown above. And the chicago manual of style is the best book available to help you get things right. Working with this formatting you will have to deal with margins, spacing, running heads, page numbers, and so on so forth. If using a list of bibliographic references at the end, use the bibliography style found in chicago as well. Other common citation styles include mla citation style and apa citation style chicago style has two systems for citing sources.
Their argument is that it creates consistency and clarity. A quick guide to chicago style citation 17th edition. Apr 20, 2016 this style guide is mainly used in most longform publishing. Jan 28, 2016 todays workout zeroes in on the section of the manual called series and the serial comma, specifically sections 6. Chicago, being twice as long as ap, has twice as much to say on this subject and offers several more variations of proper serialcomma usage on which the ap is mum 6. Two key authorities on proper usagethe associated press stylebook and the chicago manual of styleboth made modernizing tweaks in. The oxford commaalso called the serial commais one of the most divisive linguistic devices in the english language. Those who oppose the serial comma write, their names were john, paul, george and ringo.
And dont forget about all the grammar, spelling and punctuation issues as well. The manual provides rules for using specific types of punctuation and grammar. Apr 19, 2012 the chicago manual of style, 15 th ed. The infamous oxford comma commgap international language. An introductory adverbial phrase is often set off by a comma but need not be unless misreading is likely. It attempts to provide guidance, rather than blackandwhite rules. If using numbered notes within the text of an article, use the endnotes punctuation and style found in the chicago manual of style and detailed in this style guide under endnotes. The chicago manual of style is one of the oldest and most comprehensive style guides on the market. The onion posted a funny well, funny to me article yesterday about copy editing. Ap style does not use the serial comma the comma before and in a list, while cms requires it. Chicago style paper formatting rules and a howto guide.
Serial comma also called the oxford comma, this term refers to a comma that separates the penultimate item in a list from the final item introduced by a conjunction and or or. We discussed the weather, our families, and our pets. It is the indispensable reference for writers, editors, proofreaders, indexers, copywriters, designers, and publishers, informing the edi. In the us, there are two style guides for professional writing and editing that reign supreme. For example, both the chicago manual of style and the elements of style recommend using a serial comma. Please subscribe or login to access full text content. For more information about commas, semicolons, and colons in apa style, see pages 88 to 90 of the publication manual, sixth edition 4. Not that it wasnt oxford style to use the serial comma, as its appearance elsewhere in the guide showsfor example, in the phrase baptist, christian, nonconformist, presbyterian, puritan, and other denominational terms p. The serial comma is used much more often, usually routinely, in the united states.
Cmos is also commonly used for academic papers in the arts and humanities. Which style guides require the use of the serial comma. Does your resume claim that you are familiar with the chicago manual of style. The cms strongly recommends you use the serial comma consistently throughout your paper to prevent ambiguity the serial comma is the comma that comes before the conjunction in a list. These questions are designed to test knowledge of the chicago manual of style. New yorklaw enforcement officials confirmed friday that four more copy editors were killed this week amid ongoing violence between two rival gangs divided by their loyalties to the the associated press stylebook and the chicago manual of style. The grammatical use of punctuation is fairly settled. The chicago manual of style online is the venerable, timetested guide to style, usage, and grammar in an accessible online format. This quick guide, based on the chicago manual of style 17th edition, explains how to create chicago style citations. Ap style thats the associated press stylebook, which many journalists live by does not use an oxford comma. There are several distinctions that are made in the chicago manual of style. A majority of american style guides mandate its use, including the chicago manual of style, strunk and whites classic the elements of style, and the u.
With the exception of newspapers, most publications use the serial comma, because it helps writers avoid ambiguity. It is also required by the chicago manual of style and mla style. Ap style does not use the serial comma, while chicago style does. Dec 03, 2017 despite the fact that we here at get it write usually use the mla style manual for our own academic publications, we suggest the use of chicago, due to its established place in american publishing as a whole, for business and organizations that have adopted neither a customized nor a disciplinespecific manual of style. There is a reason this is called a punctuation guide. Apr 30, 2019 the chicago manual of style is a trustworthy guide for literature and academic writing. The infamous oxford comma commgap international language services. Many style guides, including the chicago manual of style, american psychological association apa, and american medical association ama, recommend. Examples of style guides that call for the oxford comma include.
However, in some cases, as cmos points out, even the oxford comma cant clarify a sentence. Since the chicago manual of style cmos is primarily intended as a style guide for published works rather than class papers, these guidelines will be supplemented with information from, kate l. The chicago manual of style is a trustworthy guide for literature and academic writing. Most authorities, including the associated press stylebook and the chicago manual of style, recommend a comma after the first digit of a fourdigit. It is the preeminent style guide for book publishing in american english and focuses on grammar, style, and citation. Sometimes, chicagos general guidelines already work just fine. If you have purchased a print title that contains an access token, please see the token for information about how to register your code. In the 1890s, a proofreader at the university of chicago press prepared a single sheet of typographic fundamentals intended as a guide for the university community. Perhaps no mark of punctuation ruffles feathers more than the serial comma also called series comma, oxford comma, and harvard comma.
The book has a lot of helpful hints dealing with time. If youre writing a book and need editing, no doubt youre going to turn to the chicago manual of style. The fact that it is so comprehensive can be both a strength and a weakness, and joe points out the weaknesses. Aps stance is to omit the serial comma except when it prevents misreading. When style issues are implicated in this guide, i have usually deferred to the chicago manual of style, 17th edition. Access to the complete content on ama manual of style requires a subscription or purchase. The oxford comma is also found in scholarly works, manuals, contracts and other legal documents.
While they are used like in ap style, in chicago style they are written. English grammar and use are the ap associated press and chicago manuals. The style guide still endorses the serial comma which pw does not and numerals are still spelled out from one through one hundred and at the beginning of a sentence. If you prefer a nonbranded term, then serial comma ascribes the same comma usage to no one in particular. Chicago style issue covers several writing aspects at once. In contrast, the associated press stylebook advises against it. Chicago manual of style, 15th edition spelling and grammar use us spelling e. The chicago manual of style also indicates that the comma after an introductory adverb phrase may be left out. Where did the oxford comma come from, and why is it so.
It is the indispensable reference for writers, editors, proofreaders, indexers, copywriters, designers, and publishers, informing the editorial canon with sound, definitive advice. In general, magazines and newspapers discourage it in order to save ink and space but the new yorker is an exception. Then, after you have a polished work, of course you should send it to a proofreadereditor to catch any mistakes you might have missed. Anything that requires a high level of precision normally requires it, since the oxford comma can help to reduce ambiguity. The new ap stylebook will not end the oxford comma debate. Nov 16, 2015 in the us, there are two style guides for professional writing and editing that reign supreme. At this time we have reason to believe the killings were gangrelated and carried out by adherents of both the ap and chicago styles, part of a. Oxford, chicago, and the serial comma cmos shop talk. Oct 08, 2019 for example, both the chicago manual of style and the elements of style recommend using a serial comma. In short, aps stance is to omit the serial comma except when it prevents misreading, and chicagos stance is to always include itfor the same reason. This is called a serial comma also known as the oxford comma, and it is required when writing in apa style. In general, msu press journals follow the chicago manual of style, 15th edition. Public users are able to search the site without a subscription. However, chicago style or the chicago manual of style, which is commonly used by book publishers, academics and trade publications does require an oxford comma.
Serial commas and serial semicolons the mla style center. Comma after introductory phrases daily writing tips. In one camp, we have apa, mla, the chicago manual of style, and the ama, all championing the oxford comma. Oxford style requires the use of the comma to avoid confusion, hence the name oxford comma. When a conjunction joins the last two elements in a series, a commaknown as the serial or series comma or the oxford commashould appear before the conjunction. Cms strongly encourages the use of the serial comma, which is when a comma is placed between the next to last item in a list of three or more items and the word and. Apr 17, 2017 chicago is one of several styles used in professional and academic writing. Other common citation styles include mla citation style and apa citation style. I wish people would both use the terminal serial comma and call it the terminal serial comma. Check your text and writing for style, spelling and grammar problems everywhere on the.
568 890 1054 1060 304 726 1623 1590 1171 1666 1280 461 1645 424 990 1437 935 196 1433 26 736 704 592 1525 795 773 1130 231 956 1171 1655 583 373 35 1322 714 1353 810 59 115 270